Vinyl Ester vs Polyester Resin
Vinyl ester resin and polyester resin are both thermosetting resins that are widely used in the composite and construction industries. While both resins have similar chemical structures, the addition of reactive sites and chemical groups in vinyl ester resin leads to better mechanical and chemical properties.
Chemical Properties
Vinyl ester resin has better chemical resistance than polyester resin due to the presence of reactive sites and functional groups in its chemical structure. Vinyl ester resin is made by the reaction of epoxy resin with unsaturated monocarboxylic acid, which introduces reactive ester groups in the chemical structure. These ester groups can react with styrene or other cross-linking agents during the curing process, resulting in a crosslinked network with excellent chemical resistance.
​
In contrast, polyester resin is made by the reaction of unsaturated dibasic acid with diols, which introduces reactive ester groups in the chemical structure. However, the ester groups in polyester resin are less reactive than those in vinyl ester resin, which leads to lower crosslinking density and inferior chemical resistance. Polyester resin is more susceptible to degradation and corrosion by harsh chemicals, such as acids, alkalis, and solvents, than vinyl ester resin.
Mechanical Properties
Vinyl ester resin has better mechanical properties than polyester resin due to the presence of reactive sites and functional groups that lead to a more crosslinked network. Vinyl ester resin has higher crosslinking density and lower residual unsaturation than polyester resin, which results in better tensile, flexural, and impact strength. Vinyl ester resin also has better fatigue resistance than polyester resin, which means that it can withstand repeated stress and strain without cracking or breaking.
​
In contrast, polyester resin has lower crosslinking density and higher residual unsaturation than vinyl ester resin, which leads to inferior mechanical properties. Polyester resin is more brittle and prone to cracking and breaking under stress and strain than vinyl ester resin. This makes vinyl ester resin a better choice for structures that need to withstand heavy loads, harsh environments, and constant use.
Conclusion
In summary, vinyl ester resin has better mechanical and chemical properties than polyester resin due to the presence of reactive sites and functional groups in its chemical structure. Vinyl ester resin has higher crosslinking density and lower residual unsaturation than polyester resin, which leads to better mechanical properties, such as higher tensile, flexural, and impact strength, and better fatigue resistance. Vinyl ester resin also has excellent chemical resistance due to the presence of reactive ester groups that can react with crosslinking agents during the curing process. Therefore, vinyl ester resin is a superior choice for applications that require high mechanical and chemical resistance, such as in the construction of polymer concrete manholes.